Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tony Fletcher's avatar

Great post as always, and this about an especially great song that did not get the respect it deserved. Interesting to theorize why not, and you have done your best. Given that I wrote a book about the man, I have listened a lot to Wilson Pickett's album In Philadelphia. It contained two of his very biggest hits (certainly by gold disc accreditation), "ENgine ENgine Number 9" and "Don't Let The Green Grass Fool You." BTW, have you ever read my book about NYC, All Hopped Up and Ready To Go: Music From The Streets of New York, 1927-77"? Lots in there about the birth of disco and how it grew and influenced both punk and hip-hop... CHeers. Are you still in Benelux, Pe?

Ellen from Endwell's avatar

This was a really fascinating and provocative post about a song I've never heard. What a great song! Absolutely love it.

I have to echo Paul Dann in thinking the image of the girl had been off-putting to white audiences, especially in the U.S. I had some jobs involving working in impoverished communities, and I found my fellow Americans did not want to hear or talk about the ghetto, poverty, or anything like that. The garbage crisis and NY's bankruptcy were also a source of derision and frustration, like NY why can't you get your act together? Americans had enough trouble after the gas crisis, and now this. Maybe it was one reminder too many of how many problems there were in the 70s.

Another thing that occurs is that entertainment that crossed over from R&B into the pop space tended to involve charming and charismatic entertainers who were willing to appear on the mainstream dance, variety, and talk shows (like Lou Rawls, for instance, who was very smooth and charming), but I can't say how/if that worked for disco and dance music. Although I can say that one of the reasons SNF was huge was not just the great music but John Travolta already being a big star from Welcome Back, Kotter, which was incredibly popular, and being such an incredible dancer. So you may be right in another comment that SNF crowded other disco songs off the turntables and charts.

Who knows, but great post. And lucky Benelux folks who had someone like Ferry Maat spin this for them!

30 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?